Appleleaf Accountancy
Client Portal
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
    • Management Accounts
    • Accounts Preparation
    • Business Start-Up Support
    • Bookkeeping Services and VAT Returns
    • Cloud-Based Software Solutions
    • Payroll, PAYE and Auto Enrolment
    • Company Secretarial
    • Company Formations
    • Personal Tax and Tax Planning
    • Contractors and IR35
  • Testimonials
  • Advisory
  • News
    • News
    • Autumn Statement 2023
    • Spring Budget Report 2023
    • Autumn Statement 2022
    • Mini Budget 2022
    • Spring Statement 2022
    • Autumn Budget 2021
  • Client Portal
  • Get in Touch
Client Portal

Slide News

IT consultant held contract for services

creative772020-01-21T16:30:42+00:00

HMRC’s application of the IR35 rules remains ambiguous after an IT contractor successfully appealed to the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) against a tax charge arising under the intermediaries’ legislation.

In RALC Consulting Ltd v HMRC [2019] TC 07474, the FTT allowed an appeal against HMRC’s determination that IR35 applied because the ‘hypothetical contract’ between various parties making up the service provider chain lacked the requisite mutuality of obligation.

In this case, RALC Consulting Ltd (RALC) (the appellant), was the personal service company (PSC) of IT consultant Richard Alcock, who was the company’s sole director and shareholder.

During the tax years in question, RALC Consulting Ltd contracted with Mr Alcock’s former employer Accenture UK Ltd (Accenture) and with the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), a client whose projects Mr Alcock had previously worked on, to provide Mr Alcock’s services working on a large IT project.

The contractual arrangements entered into by the appellant with Accenture and DWP were four-party chains, namely Mr Alcock, RALC, an agency, and the end clients. HMRC contended that as Mr Alcock had carried on working for his previous employer an ‘expectation of continued work existed’. The FTT, however, did not agree with HMRC’s submission that the long history of Mr Alcock’s previous engagement and operation of the contract in practice led to an expectation that Mr Alcock would be provided with work every day during the course of an assignment, such that it amounted to a legal obligation.

The FTT looked not only at the terms of the contract, but also at their application in practice and concluded that it was not satisfied on balance that sufficient ‘mutuality of obligations’ existed between Mr Alcock and the end clients in the hypothetical contracts to establish an employment relationship. Since there was no minimum obligation to provide work and no ability to charge for just making himself available, the FTT found that the key elements of mutuality, in the work, or wage bargain sense, were missing, and therefore Mr Alcock could not be considered an employee.

The Tribunal was satisfied that Mr Alcock had substantial control over his contracts and control over how he performed his services. The FTT also accepted that Mr Alcock’s engagements permitted him to provide a substitute but the end clients had the right to refuse to authorise any substitute proposed if they were deemed unsuitable. Therefore, while it was a genuine right of substitution, it was a fettered right subject to the approval of his clients.

The FTT concluded that the intermediaries legislation did not apply as the hypothetical contracts with the end clients indicated ‘contract for services’, meaning Mr Alcock would have been self-employed. HMRC’s determinations, decisions and notices were cancelled. The appellant was not liable to pay income tax and NICs assessed by HMRC. The appeal was allowed in full.

The outcome of the decision in this case rested largely on the FTT’s interpretation of mutuality of obligation. HMRC’s interpretation that where one party agrees to work for the other in return for payment satisfies mutuality of obligation between the two parties, was dismissed by the Tribunal. The appellant’s circumstances were such that they were not caught by the IR35 legislation, and in turn, this outcome now throws further uncertainty into the IR35 framework.

HMRC have recently updated their online Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool. Whilst the tool does have flaws, it is generally held that if CEST gives the required answer then it can be relied upon, at least until circumstances change or it is challenged by HMRC. But if CEST does not give the required answer then an employment contract review is recommended.

As the above case demonstrates IR35 continues to be a complex matter, however here at Appleleaf Accountancy we’re qualified and experienced in dealing with IR35s and can help support you in handling them correctly.

Please don’t hesitate to get in touch with us on 01472 287387 if you have any queries relating to IR35s.

get in touch

Share this post

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google + Email

Related Posts

construction

Construction Industry Scheme – be aware of the ‘trap’ when working with other contractors

The Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) sets out special rules for tax and national insurance contributions for those working in the... read more

C19 Business News Update: Government Announces “Bounce Back” Loans

The Government has announced a new 100% Government backed loan scheme for small businesses. Small businesses will benefit from a new... read more

Customs Grants Available

Preparing for 2021 changes: Customs grants available In June 2020, the Government announced that it was making funding available to... read more

NELC Logo

North East Lincolnshire Reshape Grant

More than £800,000 is being made available in capital grants to local businesses through the new “NEL Reshape Grant” to... read more

quickbites

Appleleaf November Quick Bites

£24m Broadband Boost for Yorkshire and the Humber - https://www.openreach.com/news/24m-broadband-boost-for-yorkshire-and-the-humber/   As HMRC starts to issue emails and messages to... read more

Employment Allowance

Claiming the Employment Allowance for 2023/24

The Employment Allowance is an allowance that eligible employers can claim to set against their secondary (employer’s) Class 1 National... read more

make tax digital

MTD and landlords – the new timetable

In our January newsletter we covered the delay to Making Tax Digital for Income Tax (MTD for ITSA) under the... read more

tax calendar

COMPANIES TO RECEIVE 3-MONTH EXTENSION PERIOD TO FILE ACCOUNTS DURING COVID-19

From Wednesday 25 March 2020, businesses will be able to apply for a 3-month extension for filing their accounts. This joint... read more

HMRC Invites Hospitality Industry To Register For Eat Out To Help Out

Registrations for the Eat Out to Help Out Scheme start today (13 July 2020). Restaurants and other establishments serving food for... read more

tree on calculator

Let us help you avoid a nightmare before Christmas by taking the stress out of doing your accounts

We’re going to say the C-word... And though you might want to pretend otherwise—or close your ears at the very mention... read more

Archives

Categories

  • Accounts
  • Brexit
  • Covid-19
  • Employee
  • Employer
  • News
  • Office News
  • Pension
  • Quick Bites
  • Scams
  • Self Employed
  • Tax Tips
  • VAT

We hate goodbyes...

Keep in touch and get the latest information

Just pop your email address in the form below to receive our newsletter and we’ll send a downloadable copy of the Making Tax Digital Fact Sheet and Action Plan direct to your inbox.

Where are we?

Appleleaf Accountancy and Tax Limited,
5 Town Hall Street, Grimsby, North East Lincolnshire, DN31 1HN

Get in touch!

01472 287387
info@appleleafaccountancy.co.uk
Facebook Twitter Linkedin
© Copyright Appleleaf | Privacy
Website by The Creative Agency
  • Main Menu
  • Top Navigation
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
    • Management Accounts
    • Accounts Preparation
    • Business Start-Up Support
    • Bookkeeping Services and VAT Returns
    • Cloud-Based Software Solutions
    • Payroll, PAYE and Auto Enrolment
    • Company Secretarial
    • Company Formations
    • Personal Tax and Tax Planning
    • Contractors and IR35
  • Testimonials
  • Advisory
  • News
    • News
    • Autumn Statement 2023
    • Spring Budget Report 2023
    • Autumn Statement 2022
    • Mini Budget 2022
    • Spring Statement 2022
    • Autumn Budget 2021
  • Client Portal
  • Get in Touch

Receive our newsletter to keep you up to date on the latest news, tax tips and a whole host of accountancy advice to help you and your business.

Name
johnsmith@example.com

Never see this message again.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy